Tumbleweed Observatory's

Astronomy Hints

Sci Fi Page Go To The Linux Page Writing and Sci Fi refractor telescopes,binoculars,schmidt cassegrain telescopes,maksutov telescopes,dobsonians,newtonian telescopes,telescope accessories Sally Ride, Neil Armstrong, astronomy, stargazing, telescopes, atm, astronomy blog

Review of the Meade ETX 90 RA Maksutov

keendesigns tshirt banner
Home

Telescope Tutorials
Telescope Basics
Binoculars
Refractor
Newtonian
Dobsonian
Cassegrain
Collimation
Barlow Lenses
Diffraction
Telescope Mounts
Simulated Views

Howto Projects
Apodizing Mask
Astro Sketching
Digital Camera Mount
Piggyback Camera Mount
Classic 60m Refractor
Cheap Tripod
Webcam Astro-camera

Hints and Tips
Astrophotography Hints
Mounting Hints
Telescope Hints

Astro Photos
2" Lens Astrophotos
60mm Telescope Astrophotos
ETX90 Astrophotos
6" Newtonian Astrophotos
Choosing a Camera

Astro Product Reviews
Bushnell 16x50 Binoculars
Barska 15x70 Binoculars
NexSrstar 5 SE
Meade ETX 90 RA
Stargazer Steve DOB
Discovery 6 EQ
Jaegers 50mm
Monolux 60mm
Celestron NexImage

Astro Observing
Tonight's Sky
Seeing & Transparency
Observing Lunar Eclipses
Observing Comets
Observing Stars
Observing Mars
Observing Jupiter
Observing Saturn
Mars 2003 Opposition
Comet 17P/Holmes
Mars 2007 Opposition
Amateur Astronomer Survey

Science 101
Cosmology 101
Galaxy Formation 101
Black Holes 101
Drake Equation
Pluto's Lament
Schrodinger's Cat

My Science Theme T-Shirts
Science T-shirts
Science Posters
Math T-shirts
Computer T-shirts
Ecology T-shirts
Comical T-shirts
Bowling T-shirts

Favorite Sites
Free Craft Howto's
Eric Jamison's Astronomy Site
Building a Dobsonian Telescope

Astro Links


Meade ETX 90 RA Review

The Purchase

I was browsing through a local Sam's store a few years ago when I saw an ETX90-M on sale for $250. I was flabbergasted. It didn't seem that long before when the ETX-90 had been selling for more like $500.

That time frame was before the computerized ETX models, and only the RA axis was motorized. I didn't know what an M model was, but I decided that for $250 I was willing to find out. I found that it was a variation of the ETX 90 RA model.

I was happy to see that the ETX had many of the features of the venerable Questar, a telescope I'd ogled over almost annually, but never found the cash to purchase. Of course, for the money, the Questar is a much finer piece of equipment. Sort of like comparing a Timex, a perfectly adequate watch, with a luxurious Rolex. But each time I got the Questar impulse, I would remind myself of the other fine (and larger) telescopes I could get for the money.

None-the-less, Meade advertised that the ETX had precision optics equal to any telescope on the market. The incredible price was due to the heavy duty plastic construction on the ETX mount rather than the polished aluminum of the Questar, and a more limited ensemble of features.

The sort version of this review is that I find the ETX optics to be of absolutely top quality, and the mount adequate. The shortcomings can be inexpensively overcome if one desires. Newer versions all have the same exemplary optics combined with computerized mounts.

But I learned a lot about the ETX in my observational journeys. If you want the long version of the review for more information, read on.







The Features

My ETX shares in common with the Questar a 3.5 inch Maksutov optical system, a clock drive on the RA axis, a fork mount with accessory table-top tripod legs, and a flip mirror with rear eyepiece/accessory port. It also has slow motion controls on both axes.

The Questar, besides having all these mechanical features in far superior quality, has in addition a built-in Barlow lens, an ultra-handy finder system that uses the same eyepiece as the main telescope, a star chart on the barrel that extends to be a dew guard, and a moon map on the barrel under the star map barrel.

The ETX, being a simpler and less expensive piece of gear, has no internal Barlow, a less handy drive system, and a small (barely useful) finder telescope.

On the first evening that I had the ETX, I set it up and peered at Jupiter and the Galilean moons. I was pleasantly surprised to see the moons appear as perfectly defined tiny discs. I'd never seen the moons so well defined, having viewed them generally with Newtonians, which always added a few spikes around the moons. Jupiter's cloud bands showed clearly, and it was noteworthy that no color fringes were seen at the planets sharply defined limb.

First impression? The optics were superb.



The Problems

When I tried the clock drive. I found a few things I didn't care for.

Disappointment one -- my big hands had trouble reaching in between the wide fork supports to manipulate the RA adjustment and clutch knob. The fork supports are much thicker than the trim aluminum ones of the Questar, and being plastic must be so to have the necessary strength.

Disappointment two - After only a few minutes of passable tracking, the clock drive seemed not to be working at all.

I scoured the manual and rechecked my procedures, and was left with only one conclusion, the clock drive was not working properly. The clock motor was either not running, or some component was not engaging or slipping badly.

I also found that the simple straight-through finder telescope was of little value. It was difficult to bend my head down and peer through the finder, and it didn't focus well.



The Solutions

To troubleshoot the clock drive on the fork mounted ETX, I carefully removed the base of the mount to see how the drive worked.

I found that the base was a very simple design. It also seemed different than what I found described on some Meade ETX telescope websites. I've been told that the design has changed over the years as Meade tried different schemes.

In any event, what I discovered on my ETX 90 model was a small motor with a brass spur gear that engages a larger (3 inch diameter or so) plastic gear. When the clutch knob is tightened, the large gear is unable to free wheel, and thus drives the telescope.

A circuit board acts as a voltage regulator to maintain a constant voltage on the DC clock drive motor for proper speed control.

Upon examination, I found that the motor in my unit worked properly, but the spur gear was slipping on the motor shaft. A drop of epoxy solved the problem nicely.

As to the finder, after struggling to use the one provided on my ETX I began to appreciate why Questar came up with their clever design. It's just very difficult to find room for any kind of finder on such a compact telescope.

To solve my finder problem, I ordered the elbow-finder made for the ETX-125, and it has worked better. It is still a bit clumsy in that the eyepiece of the elbow-finder gets in the way of viewing through the telescope eyepiece. One ETX owner suggested turning the elbow-finder so that the eyepiece sat about 45 degrees from the telescope eyepiece. I followed that advice and it reduced the interference problem.

To solve the problem of my clumsy big hands trying to work the RA controls, I concocted an on/off/fast control. Wires run from the inside of the fork mount base to a small hand-held control box (available from Radio Shack).

On the control box is one toggle switch and two momentary push button switches. The toggle switch is wired in series with the telescope's original on/off switch. Thus it simply extends the on/off switch to be more readily available than the original on the bottom of the base.

One of the momentary button switches is normally on, and is in series with the on/off switch. When it is pushed, it interrupts power to the motor, causing the Earth's rotation to allow an object to "catch up". This procedure doesn't cause the backlash to reappear since the drive was not mechanically disengaged.

The other momentary button is wired to allow power to bypass the regulating portion of the circuit board, so it applies full battery power to the motor. This causes the motor to run at about twice normal speed. The combination of the two momentary switches gives a fast/slow slewing control to the RA axis. With this hand-held controller, the telescope is now quite convenient to use, and is one of my favorite instruments. I've been able to engage in some astrophotography with the unit now that precise pointing and clock drive control is available.

The computerized designs now used by Meade actually attack both of my trouble points, so I would have to say that I'd not hesitate to buy one of the newer units -- if my old one ever breaks. I must say that with all the plastic used in the telescope's design, I was concerned that it would not hold up. Now, years later, I can say that I've had no problems with my ETX 90 RA holding up.







The Views

Tycho Crater through ETX 90
Tycho Taken With ETX90

I've used the ETX-90 RA quite a bit now, and have compared it side by side with my two Newtonians, a 6 inch f/10 DOB and a 6 inch f/5 equatorial. I still enjoy setting up all of the scopes and comparing views of planets and the moon.

In general, the high resolution views through the ETX are quite extraordinary. Images are very crisp, making the unit a fine lunar and planetary performer. There is no noticeable color fringing, and the stubby design of the telescope and mount delivers steady images. The image of Tycho crater at left, taken through the ETX, is a good example of the quality of images it provides.

I generally view through the ETX at about 150 power, but on good nights on bright objects I can get to 200x. I can see the large-scale features on Mars, and of course the polar caps.

On Saturn, I can see the lighter color of the equatorial band, and can clearly see the Cassini division of the rings. I can see about 4 of Saturn's moons as tiny points of light.

On Jupiter I can see the dark bands nearest the equator, and an additional dark band in the Northern hemisphere. The Great Red Spot is visible as a light colored feature. I cannot really see color on Jupiter with my aging eyes. Jupiter appears as a black and white image.

The moon is a wonderful object with the ETX, especially with the fabricated hand-held controller. With a twist of the elevation control I can move up and down along the moon's terminator, and with the push of a button, slew left and right. Trolling around on the moon is a delight.

When comparing the ETX with the 6 inch telescopes, the ETX holds its own. On most nights, little more detail is seen on a planet or the moon with the bigger telescopes than with the ETX. But on good nights, as you would expect, the bigger telescopes will show more detail.

As to star observing, At first I didn't find this model of ETX all that useful. The aperture is big enough to show all the Messier objects for example, as well as hundreds of others. But with the combination of the rather narrow field of the Maksutov optics and the awkward finder, locating star objects is very difficult. I'm sure the computerized versions help considerably in making the ETX a better star telescope.

To address that problem, I developed a program for my HP calculator to aid with finding star and deep space objects with my telescopes that have setting circles. The calculator can hold up to a few thousand object coordinates, provides an easy alignment procedure, and presents a simple menu to select objects for view. The program accounts for Earth rate, so once the RA axis ring is set, it's good for the night (of course, some more expensive mounts have motorized RA setting circles that do this compensation automatically).

I've found that I can use this program quite successfully with the ETX. By aligning the polar mounted telescope with Polaris and doing the calculator's alignment procedure (which tells me where to set the RA axis) I find that the ETX makes a very nice instrument for star observing. The setting circles are plenty accurate for pointing the telescope. With a 25mm Plossl eyepiece to aid in locating objects from the calculator supplied coordinates, I find that nearly every time the object I seek is within the field at first glance.

Now that I have a means of easily finding objects with the ETX, I can report that it's a surprisingly good instrument for viewing many star objects. It's a natural for double stars, and even most Messier and other objects show up very well. The instrument, though modest in size, gives pin point images and offers high contrast views, thanks to the telescope's internal baffling.

Since modifying the clock drive, I've tried a bit of photography through it. The drive isn't good enough for long term time exposures of star objects, but has worked well for photographing the moon and planets.

You can check out the pictures I've taken through the modified ETX at the ETX photos page on this site.



Recommendations

Would I recommend the ETX 90 RA? Not as it was when I first purchased it, but with the refinements -- yes. That said, it is clear that I'd recommend the newer models in that they've solved my main complaints in an even more grand fashion. If you're thinking of such a telescope as your primary instrument, I'd recommend the 105mm or 125mm ETX versions. But if your interest is a portable instrument to augment your equipment arsenal, I think you'd find the ETX90 a great supplement. If you don't want the computerized model, then keep your eyes on Ebay for an RA model and get a telescope with superb optics for a bargain.